Find secondhand stores in Bay Shore, New York, where you can find used, vintage, and consignment goods. Each listing has hours, phone, and directions.

• Pops Garage Sale Store

  80 Park Ave O

  Bay Shore, NY 11706
  631-647-3445
  Second Hand

Other secondhand shops in Bay Shore, New York

• Pawn Shops in Bay Shore (3)
• Thrift Stores in Bay Shore (2)

More Secondhand Stores in New York

• New York (140)
• Brooklyn (59)
• Buffalo (21)
• Schenectady (9)
• Kingston (6)
• Huntington (5)
• Albany (4)
• Beacon (4)
• Binghamton (4)
• Middletown (4)
• Plattsburgh (4)
• Rochester (4)
• Syracuse (4)
• Fairport (3)
• Hancock (3)
• Ithaca (3)
• Medina (3)
• New Paltz (3)
• Poughkeepsie (3)
• Red Hook (3)
• Saratoga Springs (3)
• Staten Island (3)
• Sunnyside (3)
• Tonawanda (3)
• Williamsville (3)
• Astoria (2)
• Babylon (2)
• Ballston Spa (2)
• Bouckville (2)
• Brewerton (2)